Well, I find myself now in a similar position with the upcomign Harry Potter show, in that I thin largely the world is being way, way too over-the-top negative. Of course, part of this feeling is the simple fact that we haven't even seen the show yet - it may end up perfectly fine! But also, there are some reasonable reasons to be wary of the show that are being drowned out by stupid ones. So without further ado, here is 7 dubm reasons people are hating on it, and three legitimate ones that are fair game but being overlooked - with again the caveat to all this that NO ONE HAS SEEN THE SHOW YET! All we have seen is a trailer and then the quick scene of the Great Hall Feast. The fact so many people are making these huge declarations from these little snippets is of course hilarious. Unsurprisingly, my "reasonable" reasons to hate (or more accurately, be worried about) the show have nothign to do with those little snippets.
Bad Reasons
8.) The Percy Character / Actor is Annoying
I like this micro-example because ultimately it is a small one, but tehre was round on social media criticizing how annoying and stilted Percy's participating in the "Dumbledore" chant was. Like, I don't disagree - but also Percy is suppsoed to be massively annoying. Like what are we talking about here? Use two seconds of critical thinking and it makes sense that this known annoying, brown-nosing kid would act annoying. If anything, that might be the best casting done to date!
7.) This Happened Slightly Differently in the Books
This is a slippery slope, as we'll get to with my #1 criticism because they are a bit at conflict with each other. Way too many people forget that this is in no way a remake of the movies, but an adaptation of the books. As we will get to, there is a cavern between those two things. That said, that does not mean everything is going to be 100% the same as the books, stuff will still get cut out or changed - some for practicality purposes, some for who knows what reasons. The small things mentioned so far in the clip are using what look like lamps instead of the hanging floating candles. Fine, fair enough, but it is going to be annoying for the haters of teh show to suddenly expect perfect adapation of everything from the books.
6.) The Teachers Are All Too Young
The casting of Snape is already controversial (we'll get to the main controversy) but the other one was how young he was, at least compared to Alan Rickman. Same is true of some of the other teaching casting decisions, and even Lithgow as Dumbledore and the actress cast as McGonagall. Now, firstly, Lithgow is older now than Richard Harris (the original Dumbledore was), and Janet McTeer just slightly younger than Maggie Smith, but as 60-80 is far younger today than it was 20 years back, they do look younger. But they, and Snape are suppsoed to. Way less time passes between Snape's time at Hogwarts and Harry's than the age difference between Alan Rickman and how old Harry is supposed to be as a first year. The ages of movie Snape, and therefore movie Mr. and Mrs. Potter never made any sense, as they were all like 22 when Harry was born, so Snape should be in his 30s at the start of the show. McGonagall and Dumbledore in their 60s. Most adults in their 30s - 50s. If anything, this was done way better this time.
5.) Everything About Ron
One part of the first scene clip that was attacked was that Ron was carefully biting his chicken leg rather than the movie Ron tearing into it like a madman. I guess the idea being that Weasley = Poor and Poor = Starving to the point that Ron would be ready to gorge whatever is put in front of him. Of course, that's movie-HP fan talk - as it is clear in the books while the Weasley's are poor, they never hurt for food and if anything Harry was the one far more "starving" at that great feast. This is a larger part about Ron as a whole. Rupert Grint was easily the best actor when they were all super young, so his performance is so held up, but the Ron in the movies was a spastic joke, compared to the strong-willed Ron from the books. I hope this more reserved Ron at the great feast is a sign that the show Ron will be much closer to the character as written in the movies.
4.) John Lithgow as Dumbledore
There is one fair criticim of this casting, and that ties into one of the my "good" reasons. However, teh main critiques are that he is (a) American and (b) more of a Comedic actor. Both are bunk. First, on the accent piece - the Brits can fuck off on that one. Who cares. His accent is reasonable. On the second point, also fuck off. Lithgow has done some incredible dramatic work over the years, and Dumbledore was largely a funny character - always adding the right amount of levity when explaining some really dark stuff. If anything, Lithgow is perfect for this role - he can bring pathos with the best of them. The role requires a santa-like figure with a darker side, and Lithgow is excellent for that. I respect Richard Harris but found his performance too austere, and Michael Gambon too cartoonish. I really think Lithgow can be a perfect middle ground between those extremes.
3.) The Characters Don't Look Like They Should
This is mostly that they do not look like the movie actors and actresses. But again, this is not a remake of the movies. They didn't try to cast someone who looked like young Daniel Radcliffe or Rupert Grint or Emma Watson. Yes, they were so everpresent that if you say Harry Potter, that is the image that comes to mind, but let's remember the first three books came out before the first movie. There were sketches of the characters in teh books, and they don't exactly look like Daniel Radcliffe. Also part of that is they were all cast when they were like 10-11, and of course grew to like 20 by the end of the run of the movies. People will age differently. That may even lead to issues - like with Emma Watson.
**quick caution, the next few sentences will sound creepy as I'm talking about the looks of a girl aged 11-20, but I was aged 12-21 in that same time period** Hermoine was always supposed to be a nebbish nerd, who when dolled up for the Yule Ball in Goblet of Fire was suddenly revealted to be actually quite attractive. Problem is by the third movie, Emma Watson was hot. And worse off, she was more attractive than the actress that played Ginny, who in the books was actually the looks queen from the beginning. It is impossible to really predict how these people will age. Just let it be and let us see.
2.) The Actress Who Plays Hermione Might be Mixed-Race
It's funny, I tried Googling it and there doesn't seem to be perfect clarity on what race her parents are, but it doesn't matter. She is at least 50% "white" and if anything reads more meditteranean, but also who the fuck cares. We will get to Snape later, but my God these are fake characters. We are now criticizing the casting of Hermione because the actres may not be 100% white? Also, very, very ironic that Hermione is a mudblood in the books and peopel are made she isn't "pure" white. Hoenstly, I need to get off Twitter. If anything, on the original casting, I thought the Hermoine actress (Arabella Stanton) seemed like a perfect casting. The clip of her saying "It Wingardium Leviosa" or whatever was just brilliant. She has the frizzy hair (which back to my Emma Watson point, she sure did before she straightened it out for good...). She may be perfect. That she may have some non-aryan heritage should absolutely not be a story
1.) The Movies Were Good Enough
Nothing will top my annoyance with this critique. There is this massive bit of revisionist history going on with the movies right now. Certainly, they were not bad. They were all good to great, and some parts were excellent, but they were far, far, far from perfect. There were a lot of valid critiques at the time, mainly problems with how much was cut from certain books (hey - guess waht more hours of film can fix!). But it goes beyond just that - so much of the pushback on the show is that it is unneeded, because we have the movies. I wonder if the people driving that messaging mostly are younger, whose main exposure to Harry Potter is the movies in teh first place. The ones that think this is a remake, not an adaptation of source. We are now 15 years from the last movie, and 25 from the first. It is perfectly fine to do this show. The idea that the movies do not require critique or the idea that the books can't be adapted better is just stupid. As someone who read every book multiple times, and has watched every movie, and is the exact target age for Harry Potter in general, it is crazy the gaslighting going on online to put over these movies. Like guys, many of us were there. No one saw them as perfect. The better the book, honestly the worse the adaptation (Half Blood Prince by far the worst offender). The one that got the closest was Prisoner of Azkaban, which the movie also cut out quite a bit, but Cuaron's brilliance made it somethign wonderful, and the book is excellent, the probably first great book in the series. But most of the movies were not taht. Most are clsoer to Half Blood Prince, imperfect bit well crafted films. This is a chance to really do this right. Us book loving Harry Potter fans should be all for this.
Good / Reasonable Reasons
4.) The Time Between Seasons
HBO already admitted they will likely not be able to stick to a book/season a year. Now, we don't know does that mean the seven books stretch out 15 years, or 9, but seriously this is lunacy. This is your damn cash cow. Despite many thinking it will be a failure, it will absoluteyl be ridiculously watched. Just pony up and do the damn show annually. Did they not listen to any of the Stranger Things discourse and how so much of the negative reaction to the latter seasons was the age of the in theory high school characters? The movies were able to do eight movies in ten years. You can figure this thing out. Let's remember Game of Thrones, probably the last show to this potentail scale, was able to do its first six seasons in six years. If there was ever a show to not get the excuse to take yaers between seasons, it is this one. Especially because, as referenced when talking about Lithgow, there is a very good chance he may sadly pass away during the run of the show, and if anythign Dumbledore becomose more important as we go.
3.) The Future Uncertainty Around a Black Actor Playing Snape
Let me say this off the bat - I think the idea that Snape was written as a white character so they cannot cast a black man as him is stupid. If anythign, the actor who they did cast in Paapa Essiedu seems like a damn delight and I can't wait to see how he plays him. Yes, giant shoes to fill and all, but let's see how he does. But, there is one big problem with casting a black man and that is mostly the fact that as revealed largely in the sixth book, Snape was continually bullied, harrassed and mocked growing up in school (by James Potter mostly) in ways that play a lot, lot different if the victim of the acts is black. Now, the infamous "lynching" scene is not a thing - in the movies he is levitated upside down by James near a tree, but in the books there is no mention of a tree. But still, not great. And not great when this bullying turns Snape fully evil and makes him join a rebellious death cult. I'm just saying, they better treat this damn tactfully, as if not, the same people extolling the bravery of casting a black man to play Snape will have dozens of SJW think pieces when the bullying stuff comes up.
2.) The Lack of Brand Name Acting Talent
Of the actors cast so far, I know exactly two of them. One is Lithgow, the other is Warwick Davis, who I only know because he played Flitwick in the original series. Maybe some have more notoriety in England, and mayn will become stars as we go. But this is a huge departure from the movies, and the one clear advantage the movies have so far - the level of talent they got to paly the adults. This was the UK Avengers - from Alan Rickman, to Maggie Smith, to Emma Thompson, to Kenneth Branagh to Gary Oldman, to Brendan Gleason, to so many more. They got a ton of amazing actors. The TV show so far hasn't done this (Lithgow excepted). Maybe it works out - hell my favorite TV show of all time casted basically zero known names (I guess not counting Method Man), and made a few future superstars (Idris Elba, anyone!). But yeah, there is a worry that the acting talent tehy have to work with isn't to the level of movies. Granted, the scripts and the details may be better and make up for it.
1.) All Books Shouldn't Be the Same Number of Episodes
Now, this may not be a problem. We don't know how they plan on doing future seasons. All we know is Season 1 is 8 episodes, which is largely the normal number of episodes these days (somehow). We also know the first book was about 300 pages, and #2 and #3 are a bit more, but from Goblet of Fire onwards they are way more (750 -> 850 -> 650 -> 700 roughly). If they're plan is to do eight episodes for each season... well, yeah I would hate taht. The biggest advantage of Harry Potter being a TV show is the ability to go way deeper into the source material, which so much was cut from the movies. All the inner workings stuff from SPEW to the Elf storylines to Potter's Army, to everyhign about Ludo Bagman, to so much more. That stuff needs a TV show run-time and episode count to breath. I am very worried about this if the creators think each book needs the same amount of episodes. Frankly, I don't know if the first book has eight hours of content. Again, maybe the plan for Season 4 onwards is 10 or 13 episodes. Maybe for books 5/6/7 they split into two half-seasons or something. Let's see, but this is the chance to tell this story right on the screen, but if the thought is the same filming time can cover The Sorcerer's Stone and The Order of the Phoenix, we have a big problem.