Tuesday, November 17, 2026

5 Bad Reasons & Good Reasons to Hate the Harry Potter Show

I wrote a similar piece to this fifteen months back, during the 2025 Club World Cup in the US - the expanded proper "World Cup" side for the club competition. I was in teh weird minority camp viewing it as perfectly fine, if not a net positive. There were many reasons brought up both before it and during it around why it was a disaster. Most of tehse to me were nonsense, and mostly Euro-centry elitism, such as the line about the games being meaningless and what-not, as they couldn't comprehend that for South American club teams this was a cool opportunity. Anyway, enough about that piece, you can go read it.

Well, I find myself now in a similar position with the upcomign Harry Potter show, in that I thin largely the world is being way, way too over-the-top negative. Of course, part of this feeling is the simple fact that we haven't even seen the show yet - it may end up perfectly fine! But also, there are some reasonable reasons to be wary of the show that are being drowned out by stupid ones. So without further ado, here is 7 dubm reasons people are hating on it, and three legitimate ones that are fair game but being overlooked - with again the caveat to all this that NO ONE HAS SEEN THE SHOW YET! All we have seen is a trailer and then the quick scene of the Great Hall Feast. The fact so many people are making these huge declarations from these little snippets is of course hilarious. Unsurprisingly, my "reasonable" reasons to hate (or more accurately, be worried about) the show have nothign to do with those little snippets.


Bad Reasons

8.) The Percy Character / Actor is Annoying

I like this micro-example because ultimately it is a small one, but tehre was round on social media criticizing how annoying and stilted Percy's participating in the "Dumbledore" chant was. Like, I don't disagree - but also Percy is suppsoed to be massively annoying. Like what are we talking about here? Use two seconds of critical thinking and it makes sense that this known annoying, brown-nosing kid would act annoying. If anything, that might be the best casting done to date!


7.) This Happened Slightly Differently in the Books

This is a slippery slope, as we'll get to with my #1 criticism because they are a bit at conflict with each other. Way too many people forget that this is in no way a remake of the movies, but an adaptation of the books. As we will get to, there is a cavern between those two things. That said, that does not mean everything is going to be 100% the same as the books, stuff will still get cut out or changed - some for practicality purposes, some for who knows what reasons. The small things mentioned so far in the clip are using what look like lamps instead of the hanging floating candles. Fine, fair enough, but it is going to be annoying for the haters of teh show to suddenly expect perfect adapation of everything from the books. 


6.) The Teachers Are All Too Young

The casting of Snape is already controversial (we'll get to the main controversy) but the other one was how young he was, at least compared to Alan Rickman. Same is true of some of the other teaching casting decisions, and even Lithgow as Dumbledore and the actress cast as McGonagall. Now, firstly, Lithgow is older now than Richard Harris (the original Dumbledore was), and Janet McTeer just slightly younger than Maggie Smith, but as 60-80 is far younger today than it was 20 years back, they do look younger. But they, and Snape are suppsoed to. Way less time passes between Snape's time at Hogwarts and Harry's than the age difference between Alan Rickman and how old Harry is supposed to be as a first year. The ages of movie Snape, and therefore movie Mr. and Mrs. Potter never made any sense, as they were all like 22 when Harry was born, so Snape should be in his 30s at the start of the show. McGonagall and Dumbledore in their 60s. Most adults in their 30s - 50s. If anything, this was done way better this time.


5.) Everything About Ron

One part of the first scene clip that was attacked was that Ron was carefully biting his chicken leg rather than the movie Ron tearing into it like a madman. I guess the idea being that Weasley = Poor and Poor = Starving to the point that Ron would be ready to gorge whatever is put in front of him. Of course, that's movie-HP fan talk - as it is clear in the books while the Weasley's are poor, they never hurt for food and if anything Harry was the one far more "starving" at that great feast. This is a larger part about Ron as a whole. Rupert Grint was easily the best actor when they were all super young, so his performance is so held up, but the Ron in the movies was a spastic joke, compared to the strong-willed Ron from the books. I hope this more reserved Ron at the great feast is a sign that the show Ron will be much closer to the character as written in the movies.


4.) John Lithgow as Dumbledore

There is one fair criticim of this casting, and that ties into one of the my "good" reasons. However, teh main critiques are that he is (a) American and (b) more of a Comedic actor. Both are bunk. First, on the accent piece - the Brits can fuck off on that one. Who cares. His accent is reasonable. On the second point, also fuck off. Lithgow has done some incredible dramatic work over the years, and Dumbledore was largely a funny character - always adding the right amount of levity when explaining some really dark stuff. If anything, Lithgow is perfect for this role - he can bring pathos with the best of them. The role requires a santa-like figure with a darker side, and Lithgow is excellent for that. I respect Richard Harris but found his performance too austere, and Michael Gambon too cartoonish. I really think Lithgow can be a perfect middle ground between those extremes.


3.) The Characters Don't Look Like They Should

This is mostly that they do not look like the movie actors and actresses. But again, this is not a remake of the movies. They didn't try to cast someone who looked like young Daniel Radcliffe or Rupert Grint or Emma Watson. Yes, they were so everpresent that if you say Harry Potter, that is the image that comes to mind, but let's remember the first three books came out before the first movie. There were sketches of the characters in teh books, and they don't exactly look like Daniel Radcliffe. Also part of that is they were all cast when they were like 10-11, and of course grew to like 20 by the end of the run of the movies. People will age differently. That may even lead to issues - like with Emma Watson.
**quick caution, the next few sentences will sound creepy as I'm talking about the looks of a girl aged 11-20, but I was aged 12-21 in that same time period** Hermoine was always supposed to be a nebbish nerd, who when dolled up for the Yule Ball in Goblet of Fire was suddenly revealted to be actually quite attractive. Problem is by the third movie, Emma Watson was hot. And worse off, she was more attractive than the actress that played Ginny, who in the books was actually the looks queen from the beginning. It is impossible to really predict how these people will age. Just let it be and let us see.


2.) The Actress Who Plays Hermione Might be Mixed-Race

It's funny, I tried Googling it and there doesn't seem to be perfect clarity on what race her parents are, but it doesn't matter. She is at least 50% "white" and if anything reads more meditteranean, but also who the fuck cares. We will get to Snape later, but my God these are fake characters. We are now criticizing the casting of Hermione because the actres may not be 100% white? Also, very, very ironic that Hermione is a mudblood in the books and peopel are made she isn't "pure" white. Hoenstly, I need to get off Twitter. If anything, on the original casting, I thought the Hermoine actress (Arabella Stanton) seemed like a perfect casting. The clip of her saying "It Wingardium Leviosa" or whatever was just brilliant. She has the frizzy hair (which back to my Emma Watson point, she sure did before she straightened it out for good...). She may be perfect. That she may have some non-aryan heritage should absolutely not be a story


1.) The Movies Were Good Enough

Nothing will top my annoyance with this critique. There is this massive bit of revisionist history going on with the movies right now. Certainly, they were not bad. They were all good to great, and some parts were excellent, but they were far, far, far from perfect. There were a lot of valid critiques at the time, mainly problems with how much was cut from certain books (hey - guess waht more hours of film can fix!). But it goes beyond just that - so much of the pushback on the show is that it is unneeded, because we have the movies. I wonder if the people driving that messaging mostly are younger, whose main exposure to Harry Potter is the movies in teh first place. The ones that think this is a remake, not an adaptation of source. We are now 15 years from the last movie, and 25 from the first. It is perfectly fine to do this show. The idea that the movies do not require critique or the idea that the books can't be adapted better is just stupid. As someone who read every book multiple times, and has watched every movie, and is the exact target age for Harry Potter in general, it is crazy the gaslighting going on online to put over these movies. Like guys, many of us were there. No one saw them as perfect. The better the book, honestly the worse the adaptation (Half Blood Prince by far the worst offender). The one that got the closest was Prisoner of Azkaban, which the movie also cut out quite a bit, but Cuaron's brilliance made it somethign wonderful, and the book is excellent, the probably first great book in the series. But most of the movies were not taht. Most are clsoer to Half Blood Prince, imperfect bit well crafted films. This is a chance to really do this right. Us book loving Harry Potter fans should be all for this.



Good / Reasonable Reasons

4.) The Time Between Seasons

HBO already admitted they will likely not be able to stick to a book/season a year. Now, we don't know does that mean the seven books stretch out 15 years, or 9, but seriously this is lunacy. This is your damn cash cow. Despite many thinking it will be a failure, it will absoluteyl be ridiculously watched. Just pony up and do the damn show annually. Did they not listen to any of the Stranger Things discourse and how so much of the negative reaction to the latter seasons was the age of the in theory high school characters? The movies were able to do eight movies in ten years. You can figure this thing out. Let's remember Game of Thrones, probably the last show to this potentail scale, was able to do its first six seasons in six years. If there was ever a show to not get the excuse to take yaers between seasons, it is this one. Especially because, as referenced when talking about Lithgow, there is a very good chance he may sadly pass away during the run of the show, and if anythign Dumbledore becomose more important as we go.


3.) The Future Uncertainty Around a Black Actor Playing Snape

Let me say this off the bat - I think the idea that Snape was written as a white character so they cannot cast a black man as him is stupid. If anythign, the actor who they did cast in Paapa Essiedu seems like a damn delight and I can't wait to see how he plays him. Yes, giant shoes to fill and all, but let's see how he does. But, there is one big problem with casting a black man and that is mostly the fact that as revealed largely in the sixth book, Snape was continually bullied, harrassed and mocked growing up in school (by James Potter mostly) in ways that play a lot, lot different if the victim of the acts is black. Now, the infamous "lynching" scene is not a thing - in the movies he is levitated upside down by James near a tree, but in the books there is no mention of a tree. But still, not great. And not great when this bullying turns Snape fully evil and makes him join a rebellious death cult. I'm just saying, they better treat this damn tactfully, as if not, the same people extolling the bravery of casting a black man to play Snape will have dozens of SJW think pieces when the bullying stuff comes up.


2.) The Lack of Brand Name Acting Talent

Of the actors cast so far, I know exactly two of them. One is Lithgow, the other is Warwick Davis, who I only know because he played Flitwick in the original series. Maybe some have more notoriety in England, and mayn will become stars as we go. But this is a huge departure from the movies, and the one clear advantage the movies have so far - the level of talent they got to paly the adults. This was the UK Avengers - from Alan Rickman, to Maggie Smith, to Emma Thompson, to Kenneth Branagh to Gary Oldman, to Brendan Gleason, to so many more. They got a ton of amazing actors. The TV show so far hasn't done this (Lithgow excepted). Maybe it works out - hell my favorite TV show of all time casted basically zero known names (I guess not counting Method Man), and made a few future superstars (Idris Elba, anyone!). But yeah, there is a worry that the acting talent tehy have to work with isn't to the level of movies. Granted, the scripts and the details may be better and make up for it.


1.) All Books Shouldn't Be the Same Number of Episodes

Now, this may not be a problem. We don't know how they plan on doing future seasons. All we know is Season 1 is 8 episodes, which is largely the normal number of episodes these days (somehow). We also know the first book was about 300 pages, and #2 and #3 are a bit more, but from Goblet of Fire onwards they are way more (750 -> 850 -> 650 -> 700 roughly). If they're plan is to do eight episodes for each season... well, yeah I would hate taht. The biggest advantage of Harry Potter being a TV show is the ability to go way deeper into the source material, which so much was cut from the movies. All the inner workings stuff from SPEW to the Elf storylines to Potter's Army, to everyhign about Ludo Bagman, to so much more. That stuff needs a TV show run-time and episode count to breath. I am very worried about this if the creators think each book needs the same amount of episodes. Frankly, I don't know if the first book has eight hours of content. Again, maybe the plan for Season 4 onwards is 10 or 13 episodes. Maybe for books 5/6/7 they split into two half-seasons or something. Let's see, but this is the chance to tell this story right on the screen, but if the thought is the same filming time can cover The Sorcerer's Stone and The Order of the Phoenix, we have a big problem.

Monday, November 16, 2026

NFL 2026: Week 10 Power Rankings & The Rest

32.) XXXXXXXXXXXX


Tier II - The "Thinking About 2027" Trio

31.) Tennessee Titans  =  1-8  (167-239)
30.) Miami Dolphins  =  1-8  (148-224)
29.) New York Jets  =  2-8  (194-254)

Weirdly, all these three can very quickly just set their sights on next year without too much fuss. Firstly, Cam Ward continues to play a bit better, adn I don't think Saleh gets canned after one season. Second for the Dolphins, similarly I think Hafley gets at least another year - though I do think the Malik Willis experiment gets killed after this season. Games like yesterday - close loss, but a loss nonetheless, are perfect in that extent to get in position for the best QB in the draft. For the Jets, I do think Aaron Glenn gets canned at this point, and realistically they should think about GM. This would be a hot opening - NYC and three first round picks, two in the top-5/6 and another probably in the teens; that's an insane war chest for any new regime to inherit.


Tier III - The "Just Bad Teams" Quadro

28.) Philadelphia Eagles  =  2-7  (148-221)
27.) Indianapolis Colts  =  3-7  (208-271)
26.) Arizona Cardinals  =  3-7  (184-289)
25.) Atlanta Falcons  =  3-7  (201-258)


This fourosme is just sad to even think too much about. The Eagles are tanking and already clearly just turning the switch to next season at this point. The Colts effectively did the same - I think Steichen is gone at this point, and honestly Jones should be as well. Don't care that they have no first round pick - tank another year at this extent. I did hear a somewhat interesting idea around the Taylor non-trade, that whenever that new QB comes in, be it next year or in 2028, having a dependable running game is helpful. Still, do wish they just traded him to teh Giants for a 2nd. For the Cardinals, a pretty pitiful performance for a season that is rapidly becoming just like 2025 - a team that was competitive to start that just collapsed in on itself. For the Falcons, something similoar. That Packers high point feels so long, long ago. Penix looks a shell of himself and the defense can't scheme its way to sacks anymore. Worrisome to be sure.


Tier IV - The "Theoretical Playoff Contenders" Quinto

24.) Washington Commanders  =  3-5-1  (196-223)
23.) New Orleans Saints  =  3-6  (202-236)
22.) XXXXXXXXX
21.) Cleveland Browns  =  6-4  (188-220)
20.) Las Vegas Raiders  =  4-6  (251-289)


I've been saying for a few weeks taht there is no middle class in this season. There is a ton of good to great teams, and a ton of bad ones. That's why we have just two teams at 5-5. This group has one of them in Baltimore.XXXXXXXXXXXXXX. For the Commanders, because they are in teh NFC East and now own the tiebreaker against the Giants, they are still alive, but you really can't feel too positive about them at this point. For the Saints, I like Kellen Moore as a coach adn what they may be building now coming out of the bill being due from the Loomis era, but the talent just is not there. Of course, in the NFC South they remain just a game behind, but realistically it won't happen. Credit the Browns for that crazy win, but that was another steal job in a season of them. The Maye injury gives them a direct path to the playoffs but my God will they be giant underdogs against whoever gts that #2 seed. If that convinces them to keep the Watson thing going, then this might be the worst outcome. For the Raiders, the Vikings needing Cousins was a godsend as they can finally play Mendoza, who looked fine for a first ever start. Really curious had they not traded Cousins would Mendoza have ever taken over this year?


Tier V - The "Closest Thing to the Middle" Quadro

19.) New England Patriots  =  5-5  (221-242)
18.) Houston Texans  =  3-6  (233-219)
17.) Dallas Cowboys  =  4-6  (286-282)
16.) Carolina Panthers  =  4-5  (219-236)

I write this before we know how bad the Maye injury is, but at this point who cares. Even if he comes back, the fact this defense has given up 80 points the last two games is enough to give you serious pause. Honestly, we are at a point where I wonder what exactly Mike Vrabel is bringing to this experience. His coordinators call the plays. He doesn't do all that much and he is losing that team. For the Texans, a crushing loss really. The Maye injury allows that #7 seed to not be fully closed off (hell, they are just one loss behind) but not a game you can blow, and blow they did. The defense still being so middling is just bizarre. The Cowboys defense wishes it could be middling. That was pathetic against the 49ers. If Jerry was less cheap on paying coaches, I would expect Christian Parker to be fired tomorrow - it just isn't working. For the Panthers, gutsy win that was closer than it needed to be. They still have the inside track at that godforesaken division, but it would be nice for their OL to come back around finally. It's been missing for a bit at this point, which is why we've seen some pretty middling Bryce Young games.


Tier VI - The "Quasi-Contenders" Trio

15.) New York Giants  =  5-3-1  (203-196)
14.) Pittsburgh Steelers  =  6-3  (198-182)
13.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers  =  3-6  (202-178)


Man, the Giants may rue that loss soon. Had they won, coupled with the Cowboys loss they would have a 3.5 game lead in the division. Now, it is slightly more precarious. It wasn't even on McCarthy - just a defense that got a bit cold at the wrong time, and some poor short conversions. Still believe that is the best team in the division, and easily the best coached team. For teh Steelers, man did they look unprepared. The defense is at this point quite different from the Tomlin era where good offenses would slice them up. Still... we saw a good offense slice them up. Granted, the Bengals offense is operating a level above "good" right now. The offense looked miserable too, Before I write them off more than this, there is a chance taht was just one of those weeks. For the Bucs, hopefully in their bye they've figured out how to bring Baker back to life. The defense is so good, and many of the skill guys have been great, but he has been so scatter-shot since he returned. That division is there for them. They to me are easily the best team in it, but man is that record with a trip to Detroit coming up a tough place to start from.


Tier VII - The "Shouldn't They Be Better" Duo

12.) Green Bay Packers  =  6-4  (226-221)
11.) Denver Broncos  =  7-2  (198-186)

The Packers are one of the great Jekyll and Hyde teams I've ever seen. 45 points and umpteen deep shots against the Patriots and then they didn't know how to even attempt to pick up a blitz against a team they've already played. I get we still need to see Parsons back, but the fact they could go from a world beating Patriots perfromacne to getting absolutely mossed at home was crazy. For the Broncos, they are the AFC version of the Packers, but lucky for them, with a better record and less competition for a wild card spot (if not still alive for the division). They should be better, and if they had a better QB they would be. In many ways, I see these two as mirror reflections, but since the Packers ceiling is so clearly higher, they get a bit more media credit, but those lows are low man (this game, the Falcons game) and so often at home which is weird.


Tier VIII - The "Two Teams Enter, One or Zero Make It?" Duo

10.) Seattle Seahawks  =  6-4  (223-175)
9.) Los Angeles Rams  =  6-4  (248-187)


It's funny when they played twice last year it was to decide the division and HFA for the league's two best teams. Both are still good, but clearly a step below and with the NFC North dominance, there is a chance neither of these two make the playoffs. WIth the Packers instability and the amount of intra-NFC North games to come, chances are one of them make it, but unlikely at this point that both do. The Seahawks offense needs to find something other than JSN - as at some point some teams will just start doubling him every snap and forcing the Seahawks to do somethign else. Also, it isn't really that heartening how little they seem to miss Darnold. For the Rams, man did they get Garrett back at the right time. The final score is pretty, but that offense is rough without Nacua for now, but the defense is good enoguh to win a few games. So interested to see how these two teams head to heads play out, in such different circumstances from last year.


Tier VIII - The "God Damn NFC North" Trio

8.) Detroit Lions  =  7-2  (257-199)
7.) Chicago Bears  =  7-2  (241-184)
6.) Minnesota Vikings  =  7-2  (176-126)

Let me start by saying these three adn the three to come can really be ranked in any order. To get some nice groups of three I put the three NFC North teams together and then the three non-Jags AFC teams together, but realistically these three are not worse than those three, but I don't think they're all better. The Lions drop slightly relative to the others because while the Vikings found themselves an offense, the Lions may have lost a defense with teh Hutchinson injury. Just brutal de-ja-vu to 2024. The offense is still excellent adn they've developed more other pass rushers than in 2024, but I can't shake the sight of that end of season Lions team. For the Bears, let's see what new tricks we see after their bye. Still so impressed by their games in Seattle and just the level of command Caleb has. For the Vikings, man did Kirk bring them to life, but also it seems no one will really solve the blitz scheme until a full offseason. Teh Packers had no hope. Doesn't help when they depend on hitting deep shots, but they had no plan b, when you get the sense Flores does have a plan B if he needs it. Kirk wasn't great but was orders of magnitude better than Wentz or Murray that it helps me put them over the other two in that division.


Tier IX - The "God Damn AFC" Trio

5.) Kansas City Chiefs  =  7-2  (237-156)
4.) Buffalo Bills  =  8-1  (287-199)
3.) Cincinnati Bengals  =  7-2  (278-193)

As mentioned, I don't thinl all three of these are better than the NFC North trio, but I love grouping them back together. It's like we are back in 2021-22 again! It is pretty crazy the staying power of these three QBs (even if the Bengals took a serioius downturn in teh middle). The Chiefs look great with Downs, but some of that may just be issues with Atlanta. Still, gives them a different dynamic and for once Mahomes had enough time as well to attack deep. The Bills sleepwalked through much of that game. This Bills team isn't too different to past ones, other than they've avoided losing some of these sleep-walk games. I don't think their ceiling is as high as many of the AFC counterparts, but their floor is higher. Granted, that matters less in the playoffs. For teh Bengals, holy hell are they on one right now, but more than the offense, it is the defense continuing to be above average that really has me glowing. The schedule is also quite light. The race for the #1 seed is going to be FUN in the AFC this year. Same with MVP as any of these three QBs (ncluding Mahomes, who was having a perfectly good year even before this game) have an argument as do the QBs for our last two teams...


Tier X - The "Best Teams... Right Now" Duo

2.) San Francisco 49ers  =  8-1  (281-196)
1.) Jacksonville Jaguars  =  7-2  (269-144)

... as realistically I think Purdy is the MVP at this point. Because he was underdrafted, he wont win it. That is stupid. But he is so instrumental to that offense - granted so are other people. The 49ers did what we expected as just eviscerated Dallas from snap one. That was frightening on offense. Of course, the defense wasn't great and it was a bit troublign that they had such a tough time getting any pressure with their four man rush. Let's chalk it up to hopefully them just sleepwalking on defense in the second half. For the Jaguars, they are playing so well at this point that a 18-point road divisional game win seems like a disappointment. They are just a machine at this point, and have a favorable schedule in the back half. Travis Hunter is being used as he always shoudl've - a brilliant CB who can play ~10 snaps on offense, and that has seemed to settle both sides. They are truly great right now.


Projecting the Playoffs

AFC

1.) Jacksonville Jaguars  =  14-3
2.) Buffalo Bills  =  14-3
3.) Cincinnati Bengals  =  13-4
4.) Kansas City Chiefs  =  13-4
5.) Denver Broncos  =  12-5
6.) Pittsburgh Steelers  =  11-6
7.) Cleveland Browns  =  10-7


NFC

1.) San Francisco 49ers  =  14-3
2.) Chicago Bears  =  13-4
3.) New York Giants  =  9-7-1
4.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers  =  7-10
5.) Detroit Lions  =  13-4
6.) Minnesota Vikings  =  12-5
7.) Los Angeles Rams  =  11-6


Looking Ahead to Next Week's Games

Byes: Atlanta Falcons (3-7), Cleveland Browns (6-4), Green Bay Packers (6-4), Los Angeles Rams (6-4), New England Patriots (5-5), Seattle Seahawks (6-4)

13.) New York Jets (2-8)  @  Los Angeles Chargers (X-X)  (4:05 - FOX)
12.) Miami Dolphins (1-8)  @  Buffalo Bills (8-1)  (1:00 - CBS)
11.) Indianapolis Colts (3-7)  @  Houston Texans (3-6)  (TNF - Prime)
10.) Pittsburgh Steelers (6-3)  @  Philadelphia Eagles (2-7)  (1:00 - CBS)
9.) Tennessee Titans (1-8)  @  Dallas Cowboys (4-6)  (1:00 - FOX)
8.) Arizona Cardinals (3-6)  @  Kansas City Chiefs (7-2)  (1:00 - CBS)
7.) Baltimore Ravens (X-X)  @  Carolina Panthers (4-5)  (1:00 - FOX)
6.) New Orleans Saints (3-6)  @  Chicago Bears (7-2)  (1:00 - FOX)
5.) Las Vegas Raiders (4-6)  @  Denver Broncos (7-2)  (4:25 - CBS)
4.) Jacksonville Jaguars (7-2)  @  New York Giants (5-3-1)  (4:25 - CBS)
3.) Cincinnati Bengals (7-2)  @  Washington Commanders (3-5-1)  (MNF - ESPN)
2.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers (3-6)  @  Detroit Lions (7-2)  (1:00 - FOX)
1.) Minnesota Vikings (7-2)  @  San Francisco 49ers (8-1)  (SNF - NBC)

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Top-10 Places Where They Know My Name

I was stranded in Toronto on November 13th 2026, the day of the infamous FAA Outage (writing this the day of - so if you are in the future and this was the first sign of the aliens attacking or wahtever, so be it). Came to Toronto for work, but stranded, I did what I have done so many times - go to a tasting menu and then go to the Moose and Firkin. The Moose was more full than normal, but their series of 4-top high tops on one side were open, so I took one, and stayed there with my laptop as the place got increasingly full. Not for one second was tehre any thought of making me move, and i do think this is because I have been to this place probably 80 times. The Moose and Firkin is the Vaughan location of the Firkin pub chain in Toronto - and i've had two projects in Vaughan, and then stayed here a bunch thereafter. YYZ is the airport I've flown in and out of 3rd most of any (EWR is #1, ORD #2). I've tracked that I've been to the Moose and Firkin 62 times in 2019, and probably a good 15 or so in 2017-18 on my first project in Vaughan (predates dependable Google Timeline info). The waiters and bartenders ahven't really changed in that period - definitely since 2019. They know me as a familiar place. Every time I go, I have to imagine I am the person who has spent more than anyone else at this bar. It's not a great bar, mind you, but a perfect one to have a few beers and listen to good music and watch sports. Food is decent too. But more than anything, this is the palce where more than anywhere else, I am known. It got me thinking, what are teh other ones.

**quick note, I am not picking any place where I am truly known because I live near there. Most notably, this would mean I am not choosing Winberies where I have probably been 100 times in Plainsboro. That's a home game These below are all road games. Also "known" doesn't mean that they know my name exactly, but they know me and there is some level of deference.**

10.) Canis (Toronto)

I went to Canis five times in abuot an eight month period - thrice because it was a treat to myself on a Thursday evening because my flight back from Toronto got cancelled/very delayed. Twice because I intentionally moved to Friday flight back to eat there - including March 13th, 2020. Canis was a brilliant place, a $95, proper 8-course tasting menu of brilliance. Only ranking this low because of course it closed during Covid. But, but, but, the owners have recently announced that they are bringing somethign back in its style in 2027....


9.) Gaggan (Bangkok)

I'm probably being presumptious that they actually know me - but the last time I did go, two of their lead chefs (non-Gaggan himself), did seem to recognize me in the sense they knew I was there before. There was a moment of "you've had some of these before" at times. It was cool, even if I was thinking more of a connection than there really was. Again, they don't know my name certainly, but may recognize the brown guy who has a Portuguese last name (it helps the main exec chef is Portuguese). 


8.) Hop Scholar Ale House (Woodlands)

My peak going here was in my 2018 project in Houston in teh Woodlands, where Hop Scholar was a brilliant little reprieve. They had surprisingly a lot of bartenders for a local suburb beer bar, but the Wednesday and Thursday night crew got used to me after a while. I will say, helps that two of them were fairly cute girls. The only reason this doesn't rank higher up is that they changed most of them post Covid, especially in teh last couple years where they opened a sister cocktail bar / speakeasy type place. Still a great spot, just not the same bartenders as before (and of course, the cuties left).


7.) Borago (Santiago)

Much like with Gaggan, in no way does head chef Rodolfo Guzman know who I am. But this makes the list because one specific person very much does and remembered me across visits eleven months apart - one of their sommeliers. Now, there is a very specific reason - on my 2025 Feb trip there, I overheard him talking to another table and he mentioned Eno Terra and Mediterra, two Princeton restaurants. I flagged him over, apologized for overhearing and asked him, and he mentioned he came to the US to study (wime, mostly) and worked as the sommelier for the Momo Group, a restaurant group in Princeton. I've eaten at those restaurants a dozen times - probably saw him. More than that, the Momo family who runs it, their daughter Alessandra was in my class in first and second grade. Completely lost touch, but still, a crazy coincidence. When we went back in Jan '26 with my parents, he wasn't serving our table, but recongized me and came over to say hello. Craziness, but very real. Hopefully he is still there - granted not many places to go upwards if you are a sommelier in Chile.


6.) Cause Effect (Cape Town)

If this was just judging off of 2016-2022, this would be higher up the list. At that point, Cause Effect was still in its infancy, and their set of mixologists were fairly consistent through each trip. I definitely was a recongized face on my once every two year trip down there in that period. Then I went in 2023 with my parents, but by this point they had opened a couple more locations, and started to rotate mixologists and hire new ones. A couple still remembered me and found it a hoot that I brought my parents. They gave them a great time, which was awesome. Sadly, on two more visits they've rotated more and more. The place is still great, but if this was going off of most recent trips, or any guess of the future, this wouild be lower, but base it on 2016-2022 and it should be higher.


5.) Actinolite (Toronto)

I've been in a long search to find a replacement for Canis and the closest I've come, both in price, food and the fact they know me is Actinolite, a wonderful seemingly youthful, young chef focused tasting menu spot in Toronto. The menu changes seasonally, but the staff never does, and I don't think any restaurant does a better job of remembering me. Maybe they have some CRM type system to tell them who I am, but this time when I entered before I even checked in at the front, one of the waiters who knows me walked over from the back to bring me in and apologize that they didn't ahve a seat at the bar (where I could chat with them). I guess a weird thing to apologize for, but it still was a nice thought. The food is excellent by the way - there''s a reason I go back (four times now) and its not because they know me, but that definitely is a great little bonus.


4.) The Observatory (Ho Chi Minh City)

I first went to the Observatory in 2019, and have returned four times from 2022-2026. Somehow, a lot of the people that work there haven't changed. Now I guess it shouldn't be too surprising since the workers are all locals and The Observatory, if anything, has only grown in standing within HCMC since then. Specifically a couple of their main bartenders definitely now me at this point - giving me a quick dap and mini-hug each day, including between trips. There's literally hundreds taht come through each weekend, in darkness and haze, and somehow I am somewhat memorable, which is cool. Out of sheer absurdity of being remembered in a place, this is high up, even if it is somewhat surface (no way any of them know my name).


3.) 


2.) Clark Street Ale House (Chicago)

There's a duration reason that is the big edge for The Moose at number one, but given this is a beer bar in downtown Chicago, in River North, it may be my most impressive work. From the time we opened our office in Chicago in 2022, I've been there probably 20 times now, and been the Clark Street Ale House probably 40. They haven't changed bartenders (despite a wholesale decor upgrade) and the core four of them are teh same - all interesting and cool in different ways. Yes, two are girls and one especially is incredibly attractive in a spunky way, she was the first to rememebr my name and still greets me with a loud "how's it going Daniel!" when she sees me. The main two men one also greet me with fist bumps and what not. Yeah, it helps I order 3-4 beers each time, but the amount of time and money I've spent earned me the privelige of getting a 2-top and space for my laptop and never even as ask by anyone to move even if it is crowded. Clark Street Ale House is a brilliant spot and I've very much made it my own.


1.) The Moose and Firkin (Toronto)

I said it all upfront. The Moose and Firkin is my platonic ideal of a pub/beer bar for me to be well known at. It does not ahve the best selection (the now closed Barhop Brewco was better in that regard in Toronto itself), but it is good enoguh, with good enough food, and this super local, exurb vibe taht was lovely. Not sure why I've always been attracted to The Moose, but it works. They know me. I know it. I am not ashamed at all that outside my direct places I live, this is the place more than any otehrs where people know my name.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The Blue Wave and Bluexas

I'm a Democrat. Not registered (would never want to annoyance of political calls and what-not that goes along with that), but I've only voted blue before. That won't change. I considering myself a moderate democrat, but definitely still one. So of course, I was ecstatic about last Tuesday, the bluest of blue wave. Things we never thought we would see again, like Democrats winning senate races in South Carolina, Kansas, Iowa, and even seemingly Missi-fucking-ssippi. Some of that was in the polls - certainly the Democrafts having real chances in Kansas and Iowa, but the others not so much. Most polls had teh Dems up +10 nationally. As expected, there was a ton of hand-wringing around polls underrating the GOP like it did during the Trump wins in 2016 and 2024. Of course, it underrated democrats. For the first time since 2012, the Democrats had a fun election night. 

It was a long 14 years in between, with two awful presidential year losses in 2016 and 2024 (both as harrowing as the last), and rough midterms and 2014 and 2022 (though 2022 had a silver lining that it was one of teh best performances by the party in power, the Democrats actually gaining a senate seat). 2020 was fun, but it took forever to realize it, with the election not being called until days later. Yes, there was that moment after midnight where the NYT Needle suddenly shifted to predicting Biden would win the remaining states and win teh election, so it was a few days of watching that dream come true, but it still took days.

This was over by 10pm in all honesty. It was over when Ossoff won so easily Georgia was called at 8:30. Hell, it arguably was one at 7:05 whem that first batch of votes in some random right-leaning county in Indianapolis had a giant leftward shift. The rest was gravy. I forgot how fun it is to flip around CNN, MSNBC (fuck off calling it MSNOW) and of course FOX News on a night like this. FOX was particularly fun watching them all realize in real time how bad things were. Those two minutes when Texas was called for first Talarico and then Hijonosa was just brilliance. You could also see the main hosts in Bret Baier and main pol Britt Hume try to steer things back to reality when the random other blondes and weirdos did their best to pretend it wasn't a huge repudiation of Trump.

Of course, MSNBC took things too far the other way. CNN was a reasonable middle ground, with even usual annoying gnat Scott Jennings being reasonable and quippy. Yes, he raised the rigth point that the Dems have to do somethign with this two year period running congress, but Trump remains so damn unpopular, it may not matter. Yes, 2028 may not be 2026, but the last time there was a blue wave of this magnitude in a midterm it was 2006, and then we saw 2008 with one of the great Democrat nights of all time. Sure, it took the onset of a global recession to get us there - but hey, the way AI and the market is trending, even that part may come true.

I do want to turn the sights on 2028 as part of this, because the biggest outcome of all to me is the white whale democrats have been chasing since 2008 or so - the year when they won so dominantly in a changing country demographically there were literally stories written that they would never lose. As 2010 so quickly showed, that was bunk and over the years they threw away that edge - with minorities still largely voting blue but way less so - including some worrying trends in 2024. Well, they all seemed to give Trump another shot. As expected, he failed miserably, and they all swung back and we had Texas go blue. Sure, even more red states did but the big headline is taht one. Because truly, if that is sustainable - than this whole thing is a wrap.

Texas was the Democrats white whale, the Lucy's Football, because of how important it can be. The 40 electoral votes, the highly Latino population, the growing Asian and Tech-focused population. The demographics are tehre for it to work. Hell, it nearly did in 2018 when Ted Cruz narrowly beat Beto O'Rourke, beating off a mild blue wave - more reliastically a blue trickle. In 2020, Trump only won Texas by six points (a gap that was 16 as recently as 2012 when Obama won the overall election easily). In 2024, it balooned back up to 14, but again there were factors that made that unique. Arguably, the complete swing the other way of those same factors (the Latino vote, largely, as it pertains to Texas) can make people say 2026 is unique. Maybe it is, but either way Texas is in play.

The most important result wasn't even Talarico winning by 12. He beat a uniquely shitty candidate in Ken Paxton, just as Annie Andrews did so in South Carolina. Paxton was maybe the worst Senate candidate this side of Roy Moore - a convicted cheat, a marriage cheat, a pedo defender, and above all of that a complete void of charisma. I don't know if Jon Cornyn won the primary would he have beat Talarico, but the fact that is a question belies the true point. Even in a blue wave, even against a bad candidate, for a Democrat to win a statewide race in Texas by 12 is ridiculous.

Nearly so is Gina Hinojosa beating Greg Abbott by seven. Sure, Abbott himself isn't all that popular, but he is a three term incumbent with some level of connection to the people of Texas, and he lost rather easily (remember, Hinojosa won by a bigger margin against Abbott than Trump did over Biden in Texas in 2020). Further down, the Democrats won the state House, they won all four seats that were open in the State Supreme Court. They won basically all statewide races. It was a blue wave in micro in Texas itself. That is staggering. You get the odd Senate race that goes against the general trend in a state - again see Kansas, Iowa, South Carolina and Mississippi - I would put good money none of these states go blue for President in 2028. But to win basically all races is meaningful.

The point around the Democrats needing to not throw away the next two years of good will is a great one, but there is an interesting case for Texas that I think can make this sustainable. First, some of the trends that made Texas go more blue than other red states are more Trump and ICE-specific, namely the Latino community not realizing teh extent to which Trump's immigration crackdown and gestapo tactics would be. Now, we can all point and laugh and say they were dumb to not realize this, but at least they seemingly learned the lesson. Those border town districts that swung heavily red in 2024 swung back with a crazy vengeance. Second, there is solid evidence the data center issue is big in Texas and unlikely to go away. Third, this is the first time in generations Texas has a Democrat governer. For decades, the only experience Texas had with Democrats in power was in the White House - having a Democrat governor is different. Positive view of that can be a meaningful, lasting change.

Texas turning blue in 2028 is of course a potential fools errand as well. Certainly, there is a good chance it swings back, and there is a risk the Democrats see this as at least a toss up that they over invest in Texas when they should not be (taking funds away from other swing states), but honestly I don't see how we can leave the 2026 election and say this isn't a swing state. Given the size, it is the most meaningful swing state maybe ever. The comp the optimists are pointing to is California, that went from deep red under Reagan, to close in 1988 when Bush Sr won, to clear blue in 1992 with Clinton and has been solid, solid blue ever since. If that happens with Texas... again, game over. Yes, even if Trump lost Texas in 2024, he would've won the election, but a world where Texas goes blue but all of PA, GA, WI, MI all go red is hard to trust, and if Trump didn't win Texas in 2024, he would have just 272 electoral votes.

The end scenario is there, it is staring the Democrats in the face, and in that way James Talarico, and I think moreso Gina Hijonosa have a lot really riding on them. Of course, the GOP knows the importance of Texas as well, and while some of the talking heads on FOX News will pretend this is all one nightmare random moment in time, the GOP machine will realize how importnat it is to turn the next two years in Texas into utter gridlock and tell all the Texans "see, this is what happens when you go blue." In many respects, other than a potential AI-driven market crash, or war, the most important developments of the next two years is simply what happens in Texas - or as one can only hope, what happens in Bluexas.

Two Parter on Trades (Hellebuyck and the NFL Deadline)

I haven't done a pure rambling type post in a while, and I don't think this qualifies either. This is three specific things, three short posts in one. One of which I should have written about last week when it was a bit fresher - us being roughly 24 hours of course past the blue wave of hope. The second is somethign more personal, the whole saga around Connor Hellebuyck not playing against the Jets in Winnipeg, and a third around the arms race of the NFL Trade Deadline, one of the more interesting ones in recent years. You know: politics, NHL trade demand drama and NFL trades - the big three! But anyway, let's start with realistically the most meaningless one - teh Hellebuyck stuff:

Connor Hellebuyck and the Return to Winnipeg Drama

For a few years now there has been a steady exodus of star US-born hockey players who were playing in Canada making their way down to the US. This started well before the 2025 Four Nations Face Off and 2026 Olympics, though definitely those two events, and most critically the latter of which, kicked it into hyperdrive. This also came in parallel with an overall panic of players fleeing to low/no-state income tax states (Florida mainly) and away from Canada and its draconian provincial taxes (maybe an exaggeration...). 

The first domino was probably Matt Tkachuk who was traded down to Florida ahead of the 2022-23 season, where he turned the Panthers into a rising team into a juggernaut that made three straight finals trips and won two cups. But more recently it has been Quinn Hughes, then Brady Tkachuk, and of course Connor Hellebuyck, the three time Vezina winning goalie, former MVP, and rock for the Jets asking out of Winnipeg two years into a five year deal. He made it clear he wanted to go the US and play for a contender. The Devils gave him those things. But now the Devils, and Hellebuyck himself, are in hot, hot water for resting Connor in the return to Winnipeg.

There's so many ways this story can go, but even as a Devils fan, I hate the fact he's being rested. I hate the fact the Devils put a line so insufferable as resting him due to "decreasing their win probability", which is trolling at best and just so dense at worst. Yes, tehre are some practical reasons to rest Hellebuyck - someone still getting into season shape after missing six weeks. The Devils have two critical division games against Washington coming up, and at a macro-level, resting your starter on the road in Winnipeg is reasonable. Two problems - first they didn't really explain it that way, and second this isn't at a macro level.

At a micro level, this looks bad for everyone. For the Devils for shielding their star, for the star for needing to be shielded, adn for the Devils again for ruining what could have been a marketable regular season New Jersey v Winnipeg game! The Devils are probably the biggest loser (indeed, they lost!), but on Hellebuyck - this just looks bad. It's bad enough to ask out 15 months into a giant contract. It's bad enough to say you only want to play in teh US. It's bad enough to play the "I am apolitical" card when you attend the State of the Union and receive a Medal of Freedom (way more "political" than just a White House appearance as part of the team). All of that looks bad, but is still forgiveable - not playing this game is not. Yes, the Devils may have pushed for this move anyway, but if you are Hellebuyck you tetll them no - I want this game in Winnipeg. I deserve to face the music. Sit me against Washington or against Toronto (their prior game). Looks abd for what could've been a super cool, interesting moment for the league.


The NFL Trade Deadline - Proper Rambling Style

= I don't know if this has been the most active deadline in recent memory, but the first where so many teams with good records took on what seemed to be an arms race. Other than the Cousins move, no real crazy league-altering things, but a lot of good teams getting guys. I do worry if a bit shortsighted - you can use the "there's no outright dominant team" logic to say this is a year to go all-in, but if that is true it is also a year to not overstretch yourself.

= Ironically, if there is a great team by the stats, it is Jacksonville, and they were the busiest engaging in somehow wanting to rebuild the defense. The Bates move is excellent - a great safety on a short contract. The Davis move is lunacy - a good player to be sure but not worth a 1st and a 2nd (admittedly the 2nd is in 2029). Yes, the Jags figure to pick really late in teh 1st roudn, but still quite a risk. Also I don't know if you can just plug guys into a scheme midway through, and a defense that was already playing well. If there was a team who was probably in position to just let the vibes and success ride, it was them.

= The biggest move is Cousins, for sure. In writing up the end of the power rankings yesterday, I was already talking about teh Vikings half expecting them to do something at QB. It was too obvious, and Cousins too obvious as the answer. A really nice fit - he knows the offense, most of the weapons and is playing well. Makes the NFC North all the more exciting, and raises the Vikings Super Bowl odds up to probably 5% or something (up from "Fuck No" with Wentz).

= The Chiefs getting Downs is fine but underwhelming. They know they need help at receiver and the answer is to get a slot guy who has better traits tahn production (sure, some of that is the team he was on). They didn't really solve their deep threat problem other than hoping Rice and Worthy stay healthy. Losing Tyquan Thornton was such a loss. There was the dream of Tyreek, but I guess we'll settle for the Colts #2 receiver.

= Not sure what the 49ers are doing with Keenan Allen other than taking an extreme flier, and hoping that beteween him, Mike Evans (should be back soon), Brandin Crooks (ditto) they have one competent dependable receiver. Obviously they gave up nothing, but you would want something a bit better. They should ahve been going after a Josh Downs type, and the Chiefs should have been shopping harder.

= A bit surprising the Rams did nothing, but I do get the sense they know this isn't their year. There was a brilliant theory/idea out there that they shoudl embrace the end and trade Stafford to teh Vikings for a big haul. I assume that never went anywhere but them doing nothing was odd. They have a clear chance of missing the playoffs and didn't do anything to change their likelihood.

= For the Colts, the big sellers, I can't leave this bit underwhelmed at the return. Most of the guys they traded are on expiring deals (Nelson, Buckner, Downs) but the collective haul was fairly blah. And it seems they had deals of at least a 2nd rounder for Jonathan Taylor and didn't pull the trigger? If you are going to tank and rebuild, go all in. 

= Finally, teh Bills move for Hooker is an intriguing one, but I worry it is a bit revealing as well. The Bills defense has feasted on turnovers, and Hooker does as well (especially against Burrow, I guess). This seems they are doubling down on being a turnover-reliant defense, which is just something that has too much variance week to week. I would have preferred them try to get more DL help or LB help. Still, they remain in good position overall.

= On the whole, nearly all my top-ranked teams did something (including earlier moves like Simmons to the Bears) and sets us up further for what I think is the largest gap between the playoff teams and the non-playoff teams. The bottom third of the league is as weak as ever. The top third is better than ever, even if there is no outright great team. But let's be honest, Jacksonville is, doubly so if their trades work.

Actually, now thinking teh Blue Wave deserves its own post, both a combination of having enough to say about it, and of course it being a wee bit more important than sports.

Monday, November 9, 2026

NFL 2026: Week 9 Power Rankings & The Rest

Tier I - The Lets Get This Over With Trio

32.) Los Angeles Chargers  =  0-8  (121-219)
31.) Miami Dolphins  =  1-7  (126-200)
30.) Tennessee Titans  =  1-7  (144-199)

The Chargers are quickly becoming the most disappointing team maybe of all time - they wre a 10.5 O/U win total team before the year started. Whats shocking is how consistently bad they have been and how much worse it has become. Herbert is broken. The team is broken. Fire them all. Move them back to San Diego. Do something dammit. For the Dolphins and Titans, some signs of life in recent weeks - a team that is at least trying hard in Miami and signs of life from Cam Ward. Both positive developments, but these are teams that were expected to be bad (though not this bad, in the case of the Titans) and have remained bad.


Tier II - The Open For Business Trio

29.) Philadelphia Eagles  =  2-7  (148-221)
28.) Indianapolis Colts  =  2-7  (184-249)
27.) New York Jets  =  2-7  (182-223)

The Eagles have started wheeling and dealing a bit - the sign that they know the season is lost. Jordan Davis is not a huge loss given what they got back, and dealing from a position of need. The real only mystery left for them is if Sirianni gets the axe, or convinces Lurie and Roseman that this was just the true outcome of a year from hell. The Colts are in a similar boat with Steichen, but I get the sense Carlie Irsay has increasingly seen enough and Steichen will get the axe fairly shortly. Surprised that it seems, as of this writing on Monday Night, that they are going to hold back on trading Taylor or Jones. For the Jets, another case where it is starting to be a real question whether their coach makes it to the end of the season. That was a sullen performance coming off of a series of many of them, to be honest. The best outcome for the Jets is just tracking those Colts and Cowboys first round picks.


Tier III - The Inevitable Slide Quadro

26.) Baltimore Ravens  =  4-5  (189-236)
25.) Cleveland Browns  =  5-4  (161-196)
24.) Washington Commanders  =  2-5-1  (172-202)
23.) Arizona Cardinals  =  3-6  (178-255)

The Ravens Brissett trade is interesting but I think short-sighted. The AFC Playoff field looks to be top-heavy record wise, helped on by the plethora of bad teams in the AFC. Hard to even know if 10-7 would make it as a wild card, and certainly not the AFC North. Unlikely to me that Brissett can keep them bove water for a potential late season Lamar return. The Browns have had their fake good start hit a huge rock at this point. Sanders will be interesting to track, but if anything the Browns should be happy that this fake good record of theirs which was a clear mirage wont teach them that they are closer than they really are. For the Commanders, the best news is Daniels has successfully completed recent games. Not sure the long term health of the team with an aging roster and Quinn - but even if they were to clean house, having a healthy Daniels is a great starting point. Finally for the Cardinals, I like this coaching staff, but they are just too limited on offense to get any higher - realistically on defense as well, and they are mising a QB. Their ability to squeeze out a few wins may actually be a net negative long term - even if it helps build a culture. Losing Michael Wilson is a real tough development, one of the few bright spots on the team.


Tier IV - The God Bless the NFC South Duo

22.) New Orleans Saints  =  3-5  (185-216)
21.) Atlanta Falcons  =  3-6  (188-223)

Of course, many are clowning on the NFC South for having all four teams with just three wins 8/9 games into the season. To me, though, there is a clear delineation between the top two teams in the division and the bottom two. Not to say the top two are way better, but the Saints and Falcons are just a bit too limited, injured and, most jarringly, highly varying week to week. In my mind both have too low a floor and not high enough a ceiling. I guess you can say the Falcons have a higher ceiling - their smack down of the Packers being one of the weirder single game outcomes so far, but that high is well in the past at this point, and teams have been far better at containing Bijan in recent weeks.


Tier V - The Fun Bad Teams Duo

20.) Las Vegas Raiders  =  4-5  (238-268)
19.) Dallas Cowboys  =  4-5  (246-236)

The Raiders offense is still good down to down but way too many turnovers, and the defense has slid back to the porous unit it was much of last year. I dont get the Cousins thing - yes he is playing well, but in reality what that should have led the Raiders to do at this point is trade him back to Minnesota or the Giants or some good team needing a QB and just play Mendoza at this point. As mentioned when talking bout hte Ravens, the AFC Wild Cards are too good record wise to expect the Raiders to contend. The Cowboys might contend only because of the NFC East, but they are still 2.5 games behind the Giants. That team is still an unserious operation, led by what I still see as a unserious head coach in Schottenheimer. The Dak Era will never come close to any high with this leadership structure.


Tier VI - The God Bless the NFC East and South Trio

18.) Carolina Panthers  =  3-5  (199-219)
17.) New York Giants  =  5-2-1  (182-172) 
16.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers  =  3-6  (202-178)

The Giants are not a good team, but it seems likely at this point they will at least end the season with a >500 record (and let us avoid the amazing amount of noise that will come with two NFC divisions with a sub-.500 winner). It is just a well coached, decent unit with few stars other than some DL, but doesnt burn themselves. That is the recipe for a 10-6-1 team that will get beaten but not embarrassed on Wild Card Weekend. The Panthers and Bucs also hae much of that, just with a way wider ceiling and floor. The Buccaneers defense remains great, but Mayfield is just broken right now. Not in the sense that it cant get better, but without a great running game, that passing game falls apart. The Panthers need better OL play to allow their offense to flourish, and lets see if the Eviro firing does anything for that defense.


Tier VII - The Middle Tier Contenders Quinto

15.) Houston Texans  =  3-5  (209-192)
14.) Pittsburgh Steelers  =  6-2  (180-144)
13.) New England Patriots  =  5-4  (211-207)
12.) Los Angeles Rams  =  5-4  (214-181)
11.) Denver Broncos  =  7-2  (198-186)

It's funny because I can easily see a world where in a few weeks we see the Texans as the best team of these. The defense is finally playing like itself the last few weeks, and Tank Dell's inclusion in the offense now has done wonders. The division is likely out of reach (even with the head to head) but a wild card isn't impossible. If it comes to pas, they will probably be stealing it from one of the next two teams. The Steelers and Patriots have had decent seasons but there is a ceiling that is lower than you would like - be it Rodgers immobility for the Steelers, or hte injuries that are really harming the Patriots. Hard to feel bad for them since lost in teh easy schedule stuff last year was also some great injury luck. A team having pretty awful injury luck is the Rams - I thought about dropping them further given the Nucua news, but Garrett coming back may reinvigorate taht defense enough to offset it. As we will get to, there seems to be a race of seven potential playoff teams for five spots (the four NFC North ones and the top three in the West) and this injury can easily be enough to make hte Rams not a playoff team. Finally for the Broncos, another close win where on paper everything looked fine. At some point it stops being just luck but man it would be a nice for a team who is good and deep and well coached to just win a game by 20 for once. Please, Denver, please!


Tier VIII - The Lower Upper Tier Contenders Trio

10.) Green Bay Packers  =  6-3  (216-191)
9.) Minnesota Vikings  =  6-2  (
8.) Seattle Seahawks  =  5-4  (202-162)

Man, taht was incredible by the Packers. With their deep shot way of playing pass offense, if it all clicks you will get a game like that, but for them to torch Gonzalez, and go out of their way to do it, was wondrous. Parsons seems to be nearing a return, and if we get that with a well over .500 Packers team, they may remain the scariest 6-7 seed in history. Granted, the division isn't totally out of reach yet. As for the Vikings, my only reason ranking them above Green Bay is I assume something will change at QB. Watching Wentz attempt to do anything was so pathetic, it covered up what was an amazing game by the defense for 40 minutes. They have a real chance of making a statement this upcoming game but it would be helpful if their QB could complete a few passes. For Seattle, it really comes down to them not losing a couple more coin flips. They are so talented, so well coached on defense, and the run game has been reasonably effective now. Darnold coming back and not throwing 2-3 pickable balls will help. The math is going to make it a really interesting late season.


Tier IX - The Imperfect Great Teams Trio

7.) Cincinnati Bengals  =  6-2  (240-175)
6.) Detroit Lions  =  6-2  (222-189)
5.) Kansas City Chiefs  =  6-2  (202-143)

The Bengals quietly have the third best DVOA and third best point differential in the NFL. They've been awesome on offense for a long time now - Burrow having a Mahomes-like season numbers wise (in a good way). He is my MVP pick at this poin t. The defense is doing enough, but so much of their future will be defined by if they can beat away their nemesis in Pittsburgh this weekend. For teh Lions, not the prettiest win, but another great showing by the defense, which is really what is most important for them - especially as we see what happens with Campbell. Them winning games when Goff isn't at his best is a great sign. Finally for the Chiefs, maybe losses in Seattle adn Denver, the latter of which they blew a game they controlled, isn't enough to suddenly think the team sucks. Yes, their continued inability to throw even intermediate is a problem, but their offense has been quite efficient on teh whole, and finally we get some nice signs by the pass rush. That may b e the biggest development from an otherwise quiet 20 point win.


Tier X - The Less Imperfect Great Teams Duo

4.) Chicago Bears  =  7-2  (241-184)
3.) Buffalo Bills  =  7-1  (


The Bears not losing that ridiculous game, with the four picks (at least two of which weren't fully on Caleb) with the fumble, with so much else, is honestly nearly as impressive as their blowout wins. Yes, you would like them not to turn it over, but the defense held up (save for the final TD drive) and the defense has put together a few good performances in a row now. Big wins for a team that is in such a dog fight in the division. Hard to know what to make of the Bills defense. They've been bad all year and then got two layups - granted they made the Wentz-led offense look more anemic than it had earlier in the year when Wentz at least scored a TD or two. The offense remains good when not doing dumb stuff, which they still do way too often. The defensive improvement makes this team realistically just a facsimile of prior great Bills teams, this one with a better shot at that long elusive #1 seed however.


Tier XI - The Best of the Best Duo

2.) Jacksonville Jaguars  =  6-2  (229-121)
1.) San Francisco 49ers  =  7-1  (235-156)

It's hard to leapfrog the Jaguars after they beat up on a clearly overmatched QB in Fagnano. Had that even been Tyler Huntley, I would probably have done it. A +108 point differential after eight games is really, really great. They are deep, balanced, and then went out and got a bevy of defensive reinforcements - why they needed to, I'm not really sure? Anyway, they remain to me the best team in teh AFC that is now ruing the blown loss to Denver back in Week 2. For the 49ers, teh turnovers forced on defesne mask an otherwise not so great performance by their defense, but the offense remains just brilliant. If they can get the injured guys back (and lets see what if anythign happens with teh Aiyuk situation, though likely nothing comes of it) they remain to me the class of the NFL at this point.


Projecting the Playoffs

AFC

1.) Jacksonville Jaguars  =  14-3
2.) Buffalo Bills  =  14-3
3.) Kansas City Chiefs  =  13-4
4.) Cincinnati Bengals  =  12-5
5.) Denver Broncos  =  12-5
6.) Pittsburgh Steelers  =  12-5
7.) New England Patriots  =  10-7


The really only question is the AFC is if the Texans, with their fairly manageable second half schedule, can get hot and steal a wild card spot. Otherwise, these are realistically your seven AFC teams in some order. I guess the Browns shitting out a handful more BS wins is not impossible...


NFC

1.) San Francisco 49ers  =  14-3
2.) Detroit Lions  =  13-4
3.) New York Giants  =  9-7-1
4.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers  =  8-9
5.) Chicago Bears  =  13-4
6.) Green Bay Packers  =  12-5
7.) Seattle Seahawks  =  11-6

Way, way more intersting. The Rams are the team on the outside at this point, along with the Vikings. I really can't with the NFC North, but that offense is just too putrid to trust. I worry the defense will wear down a bit having to play extended drives. The rough part is I can see a world where teh Rams and Seahawks both don't make it. Not as impossible as you would think, especially if they split their head to head. 


Looking Ahead to Next Week's Games

Byes: Chicago Bears (7-2), Denver Broncos (7-2), Philadelphia Eagles (2-7), Tampa Bay Buccaneers (3-6)
 
14.) Miami Dolphins (1-7)  @  Indianapolis Colts (2-7)  (1:00 - CBS)
13.) Buffalo Bills (7-1)  @  New York Jets (2-7)  (1:00 - CBS)
12.) Los Angeles Chargers (0-8)  @  Baltimore Ravens (4-5)  (MNF - ESPN)
11.) Jacksonville Jaguars (6-2)  @  Tennessee Titans (1-7)  (1:00 - FOX)
10.) Los Angeles Rams (5-4)  @  Arizona Cardinals (3-6)  (4:05 - CBS)
9.) Houston Texans (3-5)  @  Cleveland Browns (5-3)  (1:00 - FOX)
8.) Kansas City Chiefs (6-2)  @  Atlanta Falcons (3-6)  (1:00 - CBS)

I call it "Oof Sunday and Monday" as we get half the slate being fairly forgettable drek. Yes, like with any NFL football week, some of these games will end up good, but really this is rough. But this is probably what the rest of this season will be. People will say there are no truly great teams - I disagree, there are a bunch of good to great to teams. There's also a bunch of flotsam and jetsam at the bottom, and not a huge middle class this year. For that reason you get this.


7.) Seattle Seahawks (5-4)  @  Las Vegas Raiders (4-5)  (4:05 - CBS)

I call it "Spoiler??" Sunday, as we get a game that may end up noncompetitive enough that it should be with those first seven, but I have a weird feeling the Raiders can keep this close. The Seahawks aren't great agaisnt TEs. Cousins and this passing offense is the type that can have some level of success. Yes, the Seahawks should do well against the Raiders defense, but the Raiders have turned Las Vegas into a football town as well. Seahawks probably win, but I could definitely see a scare.


6.) Carolina Panthers (3-5)  @  New Orleans Saints (3-5)  (1:00 - FOX)
5.) Washington Commanders (2-5-1)  @  New York Giants (5-2-1)  (TNF - Prime)

I call it "The NFC South / East Carousel of Why Bother" Thursday and Sunday, as we get two interesting divisional matchups, but also games that expose how weak these divisions are. THe Panthers and Saints winner would ahve at least a share of the division lead, but if anything the two more interesting teams in the division are the other two. The Giants and Commanders get to replay that ridiculous tie where both teams threw the game away - oh what fun!? Realistically though, the Giants have a golden chance to go 6-2-1 and put real pressure on the Cowboys. Speaking of....


4.) San Francisco 49ers (7-1)  @  Dallas Cowboys (4-5)  (4:25 - FOX)

I call it "Get your popcorn ready" Sunday, as man, this could be a blowout. Now, the Cowboys have enough talent on offense to keep it interesting, but Shanahan has taken pride is just rolling the Cowboys any chance he gets. The 49ers should be relatively healthy. They always travel well and we can see a world where there is a lot of red in that stadium as well. The marquis name matchup has rarely felt so one sided.


3.) New England Patriots (5-4)  @  Detroit Lions (6-2)  (9:30 - FOX)

I call it "Get Right?" Sunday Morning, as the Patriots get a chacne to get things right against an easier defense (on paper) but arguably you can say the Lions get that chance as well - I'm sure their offense will relish going up against a defense that just got torched the way the Patriots did. All types of outcomes can work in this game, one of the last international ones of the season, and a game weirdly on FOX outright. 


2.) Minnesota Vikings (6-2)  @  Green Bay Packers (6-3)  (1:00 - FOX)
1.) Pittsburgh Steelers (6-2)  @  Cincinnati Bengals (6-2)  (SNF - NBC)

I call it "THIS IS WHY WE WATCH" Sunday, as we get two great intra-division games. Vikings and Packers may have lost some sheen with just how bad that Vikings offense has been, but maybe Murray is back or maybe they trade for someone (Daniel Jones would be by far the funniest trade outcome). Either way, that defense i s still worth the price of admission, especially against the bombs-away Packers offense. For the second, this is just a beautiful Sunday Night Game - a showcase in the jungle for what is one of the top offenses in the NFL, a rematch game in an already great rivalry, maybe one of Aaron Rodgers last primetime games. So much good stuff going on. A lot of Sunday is not great, but this is a perfect way to end it.

Monday, November 2, 2026

NFL 2026: Week 9 Power Rankings & The Rest

Tier I - The "Man, the AFC Bad is Really Bad" Quadro

32.) Los Angeles Chargers  =  0-7  (99-175)
31.) Miami Dolphins  =  1-6  (117-181)
30.) Indianapolis Colts  =  2-6  (161-222)
29.) Tennessee Titans  =  1-7  (144-199)

It's funny that the AFC is so stratfied. To be honest, the entire league is - there are a lot of 1/2/3 loss teams, and a bunch of 1/2 win teams. Not too much in between. Anyway, the Chargers are now even by point differential one of the worst teams in the league. We are way beyodn the point of assuming this is just a funk. This is a clean house, including maybe your broken QB, type of year. The Dolphins tried hard, the offense is finally getting some rhythm but that game just showed the lack of talent. The Colts are trying to be as simialrly untalented at this point - I can't believe they aren't benching Jones at this point. For the Titans, nice performance and a great sign for Cam Ward to have a few good games in a row, but the defense is broken when Amani Hooker is not intercepting passes.


Tier II - The "It's Starting to go South" Trio

28.) Philadelphia Eagles  =  2-6  (137-202)  
27.) New Orleans Saints  =  2-5  (162-194)
26.) New York Jets  =  2-6  (170-188)

The Eagles are broken. McKee is not useless and I do think as they get some of the missing talent back they can steal a few games, but also I do wonder if they just axe Sirianni at some point before the season ends, because otherwise not sure what the point of keeping him aroudn to maybe get them back on track without Hurst is? For the Saints and Jets, decent starts to the season have become fully undone at this point. The Jets defense has started to collapse which is really troubling since that was the one area that Glenn could point to. The Saints hopefully rested up a bit on their bye, and technically they got a bit closer to first place (just a game back) but I do think there is a separator between them and their other three NFC East compatriots.


Tier III - The "Another Lost Year....?" Uno

25.) Baltimore Ravens  =  4-4  (179-203)

It's funny that they replaced Harbaugh and nothing really changed - teh defense is iffy and playing below the sum of their parts. The offense looks amazing when Lamar is in there, but he just isn't in there enough. Now he is missing at least four games and honestly, probably the season. If anything, hopefulyl this forces a bit more change in terms of the players. Something has to change, more than just Lamar staying healthy. This ranking is a reflection of where this team is assuming Lamar doesn't come back. However, even if he was there, not sure how much higher I would have them.


Tier IV - The "Somewhat Spoilers" Trio

24.) Washington Commanders  =  2-4-1  (159-192)
23.) Arizona Cardinals  =  3-5  (175-238)
22.) Cleveland Browns  =  5-3  (139-173)
21.) Las Vegas Raiders  =  4-4  (221-230)

The Commanders needed to show out and just easily handle that Eagles team, and while the Eagles hung aroudn for a bit, the Commanders ability to put them away was impressive - at least in teh sense of this team being potentially lively in teh second half of the season. For teh Cardinals, great win and a nice Minshew performance, but let's be real he is no different than Brissett long term. The more exciting piece is how much better that offense looks without MHJ. For teh Browns, rough loss but not a shocking one. They were way over their heads at 5-2 against a soft schedule. The softness is largely over, but the defense is good enough to keep them in games. For the Raiders, nice showing by Kirk to push off any benching push, but that defense is still worrying in its inability to cover. Offense is good enough to hang around .500 for much of the year.


Tier V - The "Don't Know What To Do With You" Quadro

20.) Houston Texans  =  2-5  (165-170)
19.) Atlanta Falcons  =  3-5  (171-189)
18.) Dallas Cowboys  =  3-5  (219-213)
17.) New York Giants  =  4-2-1  (163-161)

There's a good chance this group includes one playoff team, and a decent chance it has two (Falcons). Hell, I wouldn't still be shocked if teh Texans close 8-2 and go 10-7 or something. Or they could all go to hell. The Texans hopefully figured some stuff out during their bye on why their defense has fallen off so much outside of Will Anderson. Similarly for the Giants, so curious to see how much of this JJ McCarthy renaissance is true (and him just leaving Minnesota), or how much was mirage. For the two in the middle - both had just dreadful losses. If anything, the Falcons is easy to just throw out and move on - the rain, the ridiculousness of the picsk. Granted, maybe stop the run... For the Cowboys, that was just a disaster and it seems this is basically no better than last years team. The only reason I have any faith in ranking them as high as I have is the NFC East is still winnable (2.5 games behind is tough though...).


Tier VI - The "Mess of the NFC South" Duo

16.) Carolina Panthers  =  3-4  (178-193)
15.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers  =  3-5  (178-151)

I guess these are still the two favorites in teh NFC South. What I'm looking for is that do we get a second straight sub-.500 division winner from the South. The Bucs probably have more upward momentum - for a team two games under .500, them having a +27 point differential is a good sign, and Mayfield has barely completed passes. Could be a cause for concern, I guess. The Panthers looked a bit overmatched in Green Bay, but the offense has a nice ryhthm overall. The DC firing was a bit odd though given how banged up they've been, especially at cornerback which used to be a strength.


Tier VII - The "Less of a Mess of the AFC North" Duo

14.) Cincinnati Bengals  =  5-2  (206-158)
13.) Pittsburgh Steelers   =  6-2  (180-144)

It's been a while since we had a Bengal v Steelers NFC North race. We had a few back in teh day - 2005, 2014, 2015, but not for a while. It was a fun rivalry - not Ravens v Steelers good, but not too far off at its peak. Anyway, both of these two are just generally quite good. This is the other problem of the league - too many teams that look genearlly good to very good right now. The Bengals defense is worrisome, and it would be nice for the Bengals offense not to take a half to wake up each game, but man when Burrow and Chase & Higgins are going they are awesome. For teh Steelers, the defense remains strong, the run game remains consistent and Rodgers is limiting mistakes (other than some bad bounce interceptions). They are generally just quite good.


Tier VIII - The "How Good Are They?" Trio

12.) Los Angeles Rams  =  4-4  (194-168)
11.) New England Patriots  =  5-3  (184-162)
10.) Green Bay Packers  =  5-3  (171-164)


It's hard to rank these three, and to be honest you could easily argue to me the prior two taems (Bengals, Steelers) are better than these three. Certainly they have better recorrds and point differentials. Actually, I probably messed up. Anyway, all three teams played weaker opponents and won without too much stress. The Patriots took a half to wake up but were a bit unlucky in teh first half and dominated the second. The Rams a bit the same but the offense had its best game in a while. The Packers defense was stellar and looks upwardly mobile if Parsons does come back. It is troubling they have a tough time scoring more than 27 points in any given game.


Tier IX - The "How Good is a Defense" Trio

9.) Seattle Seahawks  =  4-4  (185-159)
8.) Denver Broncos  =  6-2  (172-165)
7.) Minnesota Vikings  =  6-1  (140-93)

The Seahawks still seem so good down to down often, but if anything their offense was more worrisome than Caleb throwing a few lazers against the defense. The OL was rough and Darnold was awful against pressure most of the game. I still think they are a quite good team, but 4-4 in the NFC is rough given who tehy are up against for Wild Card spots. The Broncos defense hasn't been consistently amazing, but at its best it has been tremendous up front. They won that game with their pass rush late, and of course the ongoign drama of a Bo Nix offense being amazing in close games. Nix has thrown deep a bit more these last two weeks, so there is hope for teh future in that offense. For the Vikings, it was bound to happen. The defense remains strong, they were able to win most of their matchups against that offense. I do wonder if KOC feels any pressure to try Wentz again, or if there is a push to make a trade. At some point you have to try something, no? Kyler Murray is just not good enough and its wasting what still is on pace one of the best defenses of the decade.


Tier X - The "Panic of the Week" Uno

6.) Kansas City Chiefs  =  5-2  (167-131)

I think people are being a bit too extremem on the Chiefs. Back to Back at Seattle and at Denver is tough. Yes, you wish they go 1-1, but if not for a confluence of things in this game (including that very iffy false start) they do anyway. The offense looked way better with Rashee Rice back - and yes I still do wish they went out and got someone. Their inability to run a QB sneak, or even get a TE to run them, is a problem.


5.) Detroit Lions  =  5-2  (203-180)
4.) Buffalo Bills  =  6-1  (233-181)
3.) Chicago Bears  =  6-2  (214-160)

The Lions defense is really coming together (and quick prayer for Jack Campbell). The secondary looks good. The offense remains strong, including their more varied use of Jameson Williams this year. I may be a bit too high on them, but I can see them ahving an even stronger second half of the season, at least in overall play, than teh first. For teh Bills, a bit of a similar story, though of course it is impossible to take much from that game. The offense looked fine but also gets way too cute. They run tue Allen version of the tush push all the time, but then didn't in obvious situations a lot. In this season, their dominant offense may be good enough to paper over the defense. Beating the Seahawks in Seattle in prime time is one of the toughest accomplishments in the NFL. Doing it rather easily is even more impressive. Caleb and the offense once again looked excellent, but to me the revelation is the defense, and more than even the apss rush with Simmons, was the linebackers and speed of the defense overall. This is a complete team, and with Caleb back, a great team.


2.) Jacksonville Jaguars  =  5-2  (196-111)
1.) San Francisco 49ers  =  6-1  (197-139)

The Jags did what they should do - anhillate a team that is basically trying at this point. There was never a second where they didn't look like the dominant team. Lawrence and the offense were playing in half speed. The Texans loss remains a bit of a mystery, but to be honest the Jaguars have been the most dominant team down to down of any this year. Clean up the penalties, and this is to me the best team overall. I kept the 49ers #1 because it is hard not to when I had them there before their bye. I do hope they can get a few guys healthier, because at their best they have been excellent. Really nice top two teams - even if yes I wouldn't classify either as dominant. Then again, the 196-111 point differential after seven games is pretty damn good....


Looking Ahead to Next Week's Games


Sunday, November 1, 2026

10 Favorite Things from You Can See Everything, Pt. 2: The Dinner

5.) Pamela Handerson

It is funny that the scene started with a bit of nice comedy combined with I guess Billy wanting to show how great a husband he is that he hasn't I guess cheated on his wife, but instead that he masturbates a lot. I did find the Pamela Handerson line well - I'm sure that was a common refrain back in her prime. Also loved that Amanda got it immediately, especially after seeming fairly saddened by Billy saying it was Day 899 without sex. Again, these small moments do paint Billy in a good light (assuming he is telling the truth of course). 


4.) Billy kind of threatening to Kill Them

With all of the other craziness (still to come) I feel like the fact taht Billy alluded to having some special skills, or at least knowing people who do, who could basically end (kill) Amanda and Nathan got too little air time/ Like maybe it was all bluster and bullshit (it probably was) but also just a wild set of sentences for Billy to air in public. Granted, this was when he was fully ranting at Amanda and of course the various drinks they were having seemed to help. Nathan kind of picked up on it with a wry "what do you mean" type response. Just a great final bit of escalation to cap the scene.


3.) Power of Attorney




2.) I Know She Wants Me To
1.) The Charlie Kirk back and forth

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

The 10 Favorite Things from You Can See Everything

10.) Elizabeth's Dad Hating Billy

It was a fairly small moment, but I think such an interesting one in retrospect. Billy by this point was already pretty clearly a weirdo and controlling, but the fear/trembling of Elizabeth's Dad in front Billy was so interesting to watch. So was the Dad's bluntness about a lot of it - him pegging Liz's issues at starting out from her being raped (somethign I don't know if I knew), and of course the strange parallels to Billy being controlling and what we know of Sunny Balwani (or at least what Liz wants us to know). I do wish we got a bit more time with teh Dad, or the parents as a whole. There was more to mine there.


9.) The Eggs Scene

Similarly the scene of teh eggs, and Billy taking it over - ostensibly to let Liz focus on answering teh questions fully, but also because he is controlling and seems himself as someone who can whisk eggs better. This was as a revealing scene as any in the entire picture - mainly because of Elizabeth's reaction. Her trying to make Billy look better in that scene is a keen move, something far more observant and normal of Elizabeth than the simple dunce who was taken advantage of that she likes to portray. Put me in the camp squarely that all of this is a ruse by Elizabeth - that she is in on everything, and this small moment shows a bit of that. She knows how things are being perceived, and this little moments of taht reality escaping the fake facade are so interesting to watch.


8.) The Ongoing Weirdness of Why This is Happening

So, after doing some research, it seems clear that this was just one of the great coincidences of all time, in that Nathan Fielder believed Elizabeth Holmes to be an interesting subject to explore at teh same time Elizabeth and Billy were looking to shop their story. Still, it is just so bizarre that (a) they would allow Nathan to do this without seemingly doing a ton of research on who Nathan is (in that he will go deep, deep, deep into things), and maybe more importantly (b) how much access they would give him in those days leading up to her incarceration. From having him be there in taht backyard scene the day of (where he lovably suggests that he should excuse himself so they can have sex for the last time), to their awkward scene before she gets into the van. Add to that the weirdness around why no one else that was around Elizabeth in those days (e.g. news cameras at the prison) chose to ask the question to the world of "why is Nathan Fielder here?" Anyawy, just crazy any of this happened in teh first place.


7.) Elizabeth's Staring Contests

Obviously, Nathan is the king of awkward scenes. That was a good 30% of the fun of Nathan For You, and an even higher percentage of the fun of The Rehearsal. It is nearly impossible to get him to break and to admit teh awkwardness. Well, truly he met his match in Elizabeth (and to some degree, in Billy as well). It is insane how long she can keep those bug-eyes focused without blinking, with that wry smile on her fa Jzce, with those red cheeks. That view will haunt my dreams. Elizabeth was a striking, notable presence in teh old turtleneck, Steve Jobs cos-play days, and even more so now. Those moments were awkward, but that is the point - try to read behind what that stare, that glare, that vapid focus means. You can see it, but can you really?


6.) Seeing Amanda Seyfried

Look, I was spoiled on Seyfried being in the movie. I am also a huge, huge fan of The Dropout - naming it my #2 show of 2022. It was a phenomenon, and damn was it good to see her play that character again, but also so amazingly weird and captivating to watch her watch Elizabeth watch her perform the original character. There has been a lot of online hand-wringing of Seyfried trying to come to terms if she did anything wrong - and I found that fascinating but also more humanizing than revealing any actual issue with Seyfried's 2022 performance. The last bit I would love to know is all the moments in teh film where Seyfried is not acting as Holmes, was she acting in any capacity (e.g. some scripted lines or ideas) or was that all natural. I would love to think Seyfried is that inquisitive, cool and real in real life - she was honestly to me the star of the whole thing (other than Billy, in a very different way). 


5.) The Weird Crypto Billboard Guy

The side story of Holmes Billboards showing up in major cities using the photo that she proclaims she hates of herself, was a small bit to show again how weird, controlling and hollow Billy was - and certainly it did all of that. But damn couldn't we have gotten more backstory into the grifter crypto-scammer guy who seems to be putting on dramatic re-enactments in strip clubs (or as Billy would call it "a club that has strippers"). This whole thing was right out of Tiger King (in teh best way), or the weirdest elements of Nathan's past work. Some shine was given to it but man I wanted more of an expose on what the hell all of that was about.


4.) Who's On First

First off, something I hate to admit, but I had never seen the actual clip of Who's On First before that - so that itself was thrilling. I knew the routine and the joke (certainly more than Elizabeth...) but never the actual clip. Secondly, I do think that him watching the clip was the closest we would come to seeing a real Nathan in the movie (that or his "no you don't" reaction to Billy). But in the end, the whole thing was brilliant. If you are on the side of Elizabeth being someone on teh spectrum and someone who was largely taken advantage of, man did her realizing the clip is funny but not being able to explain the joke made your day. That said, if you live on earth and realize she is fraud upon frauds, you realize this is someone who in the span of a couple seconds realized she needed to pretend not to know what makes it funny. Watching the actaul scene - we see her laugh, we see her get it (same with Nathan). That little dichotomy arguably was the most interesting moment of the whole thing.


3.) The First Re-Enactment

This was the one with Nathan, Lance and the A24 execs (I assume actors?) going to the house Billy and Liz were staying in, where Liz reads her awful memoir, and Billy then hustles them for a cut of the profits. The scene itself is great in that it uncovers such a key element of the whole second half of the doc ("Did Liz know about the deal?") but also because the re-enactment took teeh best part of Nathan's famed re-enactments in The Rehearsal. The best being the actor who played Billy looking and somewhat acting nothing like him, but still so striking. Same with the kids, same with the nervous laughs of the execs. That whole scene was just so well done in a perfect Nathan Fielder way, taking the whole idea of a re-enactment and highlighting everything ridiculous about the idea itself. Also, damn if Seyfried doesn't so easily slip back into that role.


2.) Billy and Liz Being Good Parents

This is not a novel thought, but seems to be one of the few areas of consensus that are positive for our friends Billy and Liz - that they seem to be really good parents, adn if anything further very supportive of each other. Yes, they are both likely psycopaths and much more, but they support each other, and they support the kids. Yes, it was a bit heartbreaking to see these two very young children have to say goodbye to their Mom to go to prison, but let's remember the fact the kids were in teh documentary had to be explicitly agreed by Billy and Liz, and secondly while of course the nightly routine of chatting with Mommy in prison is not normal, that is their normal. Billy also seems like a really committed parent, effectively largely single parenting for 11 years. At the end of the day, Liz can be a monster who defrauded the world, and Billy can be as complicit as seemingly wanted to start Theranos 2.0 with as little idea of what the hell he is building as Liz did the first time, but behind all of that is this weird family unit taht works quite well together.


1.) The Dinner Scene with Billy

I could honestly write a whole 5-10 part piece on just this scene, wich may be the greatest piece of filmed content in years. In fact, let's do that.... off we go to Part 2, the deep dive on the Dinner Scene.

About Me

I am a man who will go by the moniker dmstorm22, or StormyD, but not really StormyD. I'll talk about sports, mainly football, sometimes TV, sometimes other random things, sometimes even bring out some lists (a lot, lot, lot of lists). Enjoy.